A Piece By David Cornsilk on some Indian Law and History


From 1867 until 1906, the Cherokee Nation elected a series of Principal Chiefs. However, from 1907 until 1971, the President of the United States appointed the Principal Chief. In 1971, the Cherokee Nation elected W.W. Keeler, CEO of Phillips Petroleum, as Principal Chief.

Because of the wording of the 1906 Five Civilized Tribes Act and 1970 Five Civilized Tribes Act, which gave democracy of sorts, back to the Cherokees, the Principal Chief has only those powers provided by the organic document which created that office(the 1839 Constitution), limitation placed on the Cherokee Nation by Congress (1906 FCT Act) and those powers granted by Congress (1970 FCT Act).

The office of Principal Chief is not an inherent position. It was created by an act of the Cherokee people. That act is the adoption of the 1839 Constitution. Without that document, there could not have been a principal chief. The 1906 FCT Act provided that the Cherokee Nation shall continue, in full force and effect, in accordance with law, until such time as Congress shall deem otherwise. The only law in operation in 1906 was the Constitution of 1839 and Federal law.

The Constitution of 1839 created the office of Principal Chief. The 1906 FCT Act took democracy away from the Cherokees and handed to the U.S. President the power of appointment to fill that position. In 1970, when Congress "permitted" the Cherokee people to popularly select the individual the President had previously appointed, the only extra authority provided to the PC in that act was the power to "promulgate rules" to carry out the election.

There was no council to make election laws. That had been done away with by the Curtis Act. In carrying out the tenets of the 1970 FCT Act, W.W. Keeler promulgated rules for the 1971 and 1975 Principal Chief's election. The Constitution of 1839, which had created the office of Principal Chief, had no clear rules for carrying out an election. Since the 1906 FCT Act had made Cherokee laws uneforceable, Congress permitted the appointed Principal Chief to promulgate rules and nothing more.

Ross O. Swimmer was popularly selected by the Cherokee people in 1975 to serve a four year term as Principal Chief. He immediately began developing what he called a Constitution to be put to a vote of the Cherokee people. Since he had no authority to abrogate the 1839 Constitution which had created the office he was selected to, his so-called Constitution was nothing more than another set of rules promulgated for the popular selection of the PC to be held in 1979. Remember, as Principal Chief, he can only do what the law allows.

It is obvious that the office of Principal Chief did not come out of thin air, and its historic provenance goes back only to the early 1800s. It had to come from somewhere and if it came from somewhere, then that somewhere must still be valid, or the office of Principal Chief is not valid. That somewhere is the 1839 Constitution, the most recent authentic constitution adopted by the Cherokee people. Thus, the Cherokee Nation, as constituted by the 1839 Constitution, diminished by the 1898 Curtis Act, shot forward in time by the 1906 FCT Act, continues to exist today only in the office of the Principal Chief. The organization created by the Principal Chief in 1976, under the authority of the 1970 FCT Act, is not the Cherokee Nation, but is instead only an appendage of the office of the Principal Chief. Registry on a list of persons eligible to vote in the popular selection of the Principal Chief of the Cherokee Nation does not consitute citizenship in the Cherokee Nation. Nowhere did Congress require that the Principal Chief be popularly selected by Cherokee Nation citizens than it was Congress' intent that the President of the United States be a Cherokee in order to make the appointment. In other words, claiming that those person on the CNO Registry must be citizens of the Cherokee Nation in order to vote would only hold water if the President of the United States had been required to be a Cherokee Nation citizen. He did not have to be, and those placed on the Cherokee Registry don't have to be and aren't. Therefore, inclusion on the CNO Registry list does not constitute dual enrollment for membership purposes in any other federally recognized tribe.

David Cornsilk.